Past pollution meets present day corruption

I often speak to my ESL students about democracy. Most of them don't really understand what we are all about (I'm not sure I know lately, either), and most of them are unrealistic about the US, loving us, or hating us too much. I am always pleased when I have an opportunity to demonstrate some of our professed values in action.

Back in December, the Pittsburgh Post Gazette ran a series of articles about air pollution in Western Pennsylvania–how fine particulate in the air causes asthma, lung cancer, other lung diseases and heart disease. They told stories about the problems individuals and families living near our coal fired power plants have, and presented statistics showing a huge number of deaths above the national average from these causes. You can read the series here.

In order to keep the message alive a meeting was held at Chatham University, attended by me, my two students and several hundred others. The reporters gave an overview of the problem and several of the affected individuals told their horrifying stories—children suffering with asthma, proliferation of lung cancer deaths within their communities, well water polluted so that it was not only not drinkable, but caused skin rashes when they showered with it corroded pipes and faucets so badly they had to be replaced every two years. 

I was hoping to show my ESL students that this is the way democracy should work. What did we learn? My Chinese student learned that the Chinese aren't the only ones with pollution problems. He was clearly impressed with that. My Russian student lived in Sweden for twenty years before coming here. I'm not sure what she learned. I learned, not for the first time, that our elected officials have no shame and don't care about what happens to their constituency, so long as the industry involved continues to support their tenure in office.

The lessons are clear: in the name of creating cheap power we allow the industry to be lax and shift the cost away from all of us and on to the backs of a few individuals who pay dearly. The most obvious lesson is the ineffectiveness of the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, which seems to be protecting only the companies creating the environmental problems.

All of this has to do with rectifying past sins, but we have learned nothing. The day after the meeting, the head of the Pennsylvania DEP announced that all permits and enforcement actions for Marcellus shale drilling would be issued by his office. We know he isn't concerned about air or water quality. His only concern is to give the gas drilling industry the greatest freedom possible. Pennsylvania is not taxing or taking any kind of removal fee. The only authority looking out for the public interest is the DEP and they sold out. See the links below for more information.

We haven't learned our lessons from air pollution, now we will poison our water supply.

This is the story I told during my fifteen minutes of fame at the Waffle Shop. But I made one mistake. The interviewer asked me what she could do and I talked about contacting elected officials. That's obviously hopeless. These college kids should be out marching in the streets, just like they are doing in the middle east. It's their water and their air we are poisoning. Because of my age and the fact that I already have heart disease, it won't matter so much to me; it should matter hugely to them. We have allowed our democracy to be sold to the highest bidder. Our children will pay more dearly for this than they will for the debt the Republicans are screaming about.

Ronni Bennett, at Time Goes By, has a wonderful post about the choices we face for our democracy. If you haven't read it, go there now.


Post-Gazette Air Pollution series

The sell-out







5 thoughts on “Past pollution meets present day corruption

  1. You’re right for the most part, although I have seen cases where one person did make a difference. Sometimes it happens in unexpected ways. We had a bill last year that would have prohibited implanting people with computer chips (Yeah. I know.). At the state house committee meeting, a citizen signed up to testify in favor of the bill. She testified that somebody implanted her with a chip and now she was being controlled by them, or something along those lines. This bill had been moving through the system quite nicely, but once she testified it was pretty much all over. I believe the bill died right then and there.

  2. I marched…but in short spurts. Two jobs, two kids, and college sort of took me out of reality in those days. Today I should march, I should call them on their BS, instead I am introspective and struggling just to maintain. I’m left wondering what the stats on cancer were in the late and middle 1800’s. What were they in the 20th.

  3. Im sure thats true, not just for the students, but for many of the politicians who ought to know better. We only seem capable of seeing whats directly in front of our faces.

  4. Something just occurred to me. Could the fact that so few students are out marching in the streets be that those who can afford to go without having to work nearly full-time are those who’ve never had to wonder where the next meal (or check to pay the bills) is coming from. I wasn’t out in the streets in the 60s for exactly that reason. There wasn’t much time after working just to catch up trying to get what everybody else already had, clothes, a car, etc., not even thinking of college. I hope that doesn’t make me sound bad. But I do think that life is too easy for some people to see beyond themselves.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s